Value of Audit for Supply Chains with Hidden Action and Information

News

Published: 3Mar2020

Authors: Mohammad Nikoofal, Mehmet Gumus

Publication: European Journal of Operational Research, Forthcoming

Abstract:

Outsourcing can provide firms with a competitive advantage by realizing the benefits of suppliers' low labor, better quality and improved innovation. Yet, the supply chain managers have several concerns about outsourcing which are mainly due to lack of critical information regarding the actions of their suppliers. In this paper, we study the effectiveness of auditing the supplier's hidden actions for the buyer (principal) when the supplier (agent) is privately informed about the extent of the supply risk. In order to accomplish this, we first extend the standard principal-agent model by considering a case in which the agent's hidden action affects the extent of information asymmetry between principal and agent. By comparing the agency costs associated with the optimal menu of contracts with and without audit, we then completely characterize the value of audit from the perspectives of both buyer and supplier as well as total supply chain. First, the analysis of value of audit from the buyer's perspective shows that the buyer can strictly benefit from auditing the supplier's actions. Second, we find that not only the buyer but also the supplier can strictly benefit from an audit. Third, the audit enables the buyer to customize her contract offerings based on the reliability of the supplier. Finally, by analyzing the impact of problem parameters on the value of the audit, we identify the conditions under which an audit would be beneficial for individual supply chain parties as well as the overall supply chain.

Editor feedback

For more information or if you would like to report an error, please web.desautels [at] mcgill.ca (subject: Website%20News%20Comments) (contact us).

Coronavirus (COVID-19)

Updated: 2020/10/01

For the latest information on McGill University's response to COVID-19, please visit the Coronavirus Information website.

For Desautels specific updates please visit our COVID-19 FAQ page.

Back to top