The Student Affairs Committee (SAC) is a standing committee of the Faculty of Education at McGill University and reports to the Associate Dean, Academic Programs. The SAC works closely with the Internships and Student Affairs (ISA) Office. The SAC serves the Faculty of Education in several ways:
- serves the ISA in an advisory capacity for policy development related to student affairs
- ensures the regulations from the McGill Code of Student Conduct and Disciplinary Procedures are respected;
- ensures the regulations from the McGill Principles of Practice, Behaviour and Ethical Conduct for Teacher Candidates are respected;
- addresses issues arising from the interpretation and implementation of Faculty and University regulations.
- acts as a sub-committee for appeal as follows:
- any B.Ed. or MATL teacher candidate who wishes to appeal their grade and/or academic standing in reference to a failed Field Experience or Internship course.
- any B.Ed. or MATL teacher candidate who wishes to appeal a Disposition from McGill Principles of Practice, Behaviour and Ethical Conduct for Teacher Candidates
SAC will maintain the option to invite a speaker to present at meetings as appropriate, for example departmental advisers, field supervisors, representatives from the Office for Students with Disabilities. SAC shall report back to Faculty Council with a brief written report at least once during the academic year.
Structure and Rotation
The SAC meets twice per fall and winter terms and once per summer term. Meetings are called by the Associate Dean, Academic Programs who serves as the chair of the committee. The SAC is composed of 6 voting members:
- Associate Dean, Academic Programs (Chair)
- Director of Internships & Student Affairs
- ISA Administrative Officer
- Program Director (or delegate) from each academic unit (DISE, ECP, KPE)
Procedures for SAC Meetings with Teacher Candidates and/or Advocates
A meeting of the SAC will be convened and the date and time communicated to the teacher candidate. Teacher candidates are not required to present their case in person; however, they are always invited to do so by the SAC. In the interests of universal design and accessibility for all teacher candidates, alternative options include:
- Submit the request and supporting documentation to the SAC in writing only (teacher candidate is not present);
- Have a McGill advocate present the case (teacher candidate is present). Teacher candidates are permitted to bring an advocate, per the Code of Student Conduct and Disciplinary Procedures (i.e. a member of the University community…who has agreed to act in an advisory capacity and who may accompany a student…to any hearing, summary hearing, or interview; advisors are not paid for their services). It is recommended to select an advocate from McGill’s Legal Information Clinic. (http://licm.mcgill.ca/student-advocacy/).
- Please note: (i) In the event that neither the teacher candidate nor an advocate is present at the time of the meeting, the SAC will render a decision based on the existing evidence; (ii) Third parties present on behalf of students are not normally permitted to attend SAC hearings.
The Office of Internships and Student Affairs will be responsible for gathering all documentation relevant to the case from the teacher candidate and the Director of the ISA for presentation to members of the SAC. Teacher candidates must provide the ISA with copies of relevant documentation at the time of their request. Please note that any request for appeal may be rejected without complete documentation at the time of the request. Any requests for additions not included in the original documentation may be considered by the Associate Dean up to 14 days before the SAC meeting date. No additional information will be accepted after this time.
The teacher candidate will receive a copy of all relevant documents no less than one (1) week prior to the date of the SAC meeting. It is the responsibility of the teacher candidate to share relevant documentation with their McGill advocate in a timely manner. To provide adequate time for the committee to review the case, all relevant documentation provided by the Director of the ISA as well as the teacher candidate will be provided to members of the committee no less than one (1) week prior to the date of the SAC meeting. All information should remain confidential. To ensure the greatest degree of fairness, committee members should refrain from speaking to one another about the case prior to the hearing. An administrative member from the ISA will record minutes of the meetings and will distribute the minutes to committee members within one week of the SAC meeting.
Order of Meeting for Appeals
|SAC only||1. A review of the documentation submitted by all parties (closed committee)||20 minutes|
|All parties||2. The Associate Dean calls the meeting to order||10 minutes|
|All parties||3. The Director of Internships and Student Affairs presents documentation||20 minutes|
|All parties||4. Questions are posed to the Director of Internships and Student Affairs and answers provided||10 minutes|
|All parties||5. Teacher candidate (and/or advocate, if applicable) presents documentation for the appeal||20 minutes|
|All parties||6. Questions are posed by Committee members to the teacher candidate (and/or advocate, if applicable) and answers provided||10 minutes|
|All parties||7. Teacher candidate (and advocate, if applicable) and other invited parties leave; also, in cases where the ISA Director rendered the initial decision, they recuse themselves||N/A|
|SAC only||8. Committee deliberates and reaches a decision (closed committee)||N/A|
|Associate Dean||9. Within two weeks, The Associate Dean communicates this decision to the teacher candidate in writing.||N/A|
SAC Committee Membership 2020-21
|Associate Dean, Academic Programs (Chair)||Alain Breuleaux||Ex-officio|
|Director, ISA||Lisa Starr||Ex-officio|
|Administrative officer, ISA||Yasmine Zein||Ex-officio|
|Program Director (or delegate) from DISE||Sheryl Smith Gilman||2020-2023|
|Program Director (or delegate) from ECP||Chiaki Konishi||2020-2023|
|Program Director (or delegate) from KPE||Jessica Mociella||2020-2023|
 Faculty members of the SAC are generally appointed for three-year term
 In cases where the original judgement leading to the appeal was rendered by the Director of the Office of Internships and Student Affairs, the Director will recuse themselves from any deliberations for the outcome of the appeal process.