Subscribe to the OSS Weekly Newsletter!

The Colour Purple

I have a special fondness for the colour purple. For good reason.
Image by Science History Institute.

My favourite colour is purple. More specifically, mauve, which is a light shade of purple. The word owes its origin to the colour of the mallow flower, called “fleur de mauve” in French. “Mauve” as a description of colour became wildly popular in Britain after William Henry Perkin’s 1856 discovery of the first synthetic aniline dye that had a shade resembling the colour of the mallow flower. The dye sparked a fashion craze, with the 1860s developing a reputation as the “mauve decade.” Perkin initially called his discovery “Tyrian purple,” attempting to associate it with the prized purple dye of antiquity isolated from sea snails and named after the Phoenician city of Tyre where it was produced. Since extracting a gram required sacrificing about 10,000 snails, fabrics dyed with Tyrian purple were an expensive luxury reserved for royalty and the wealthy giving rise to the phrase “born in the purple.”

Perkin’s discovery served as the springboard for producing other dyes, but even more importantly, it spawned the modern pharmaceutical industry. If dyes could be produced synthetically from coal tar, which was the source of the aniline Perkin accidentally converted into mauve while engaged in a futile attempt to make quinine, why could one not produce other substances such as medications? Indeed, the major pharmaceutical companies in Germany started out as dye manufacturers.

Perhaps now you can appreciate my special fondness for purple and why anything to do with the colour catches my eye. Like a bunch of Instagram reels about purple cakes, smoothies, ice cream and teas all made with a yam known as “ube” that is usually processed into a purple powder. Not only are the foods and beverages made with ube a stunning purple, some come with a bevy of health claims that confer “superfood” status on this root vegetable. “Helps support your energy levels, gut health and overall wellbeing, without the sugar crash.” “Naturally rich in antioxidants, vitamin C, fiber and potassium.” “Contains diosgenin that relieves menstrual cramps and even delays menopause.” Sounds seductive, but “superfood” is a mythical category. There are good diets and poor diets, but no single food, including ube, has miraculous health properties.

Ube is a yam with the botanical name Dioscorea alata that owes its vibrant colour to anthocyanins, compounds in the flavonoid family. In the laboratory, anthocyanins can be shown to have an antioxidant effect, meaning they can neutralize free radicals. These highly reactive species are a normal byproduct of metabolism in humans and can damage proteins and DNA if not neutralized. But humans are not giant test tubes, and there are no studies that have shown anthocyanin supplements to have an impact on any condition in people. However, anthocyanins are responsible for the colour of many plants, and plant-based diets have been shown to have health benefits, so suggestions to consume foods containing anthocyanins are valid. That would include ube, as long as it is consumed as a whole food. Like a potato, it can be boiled, mashed or fried. But coloring tea or ice cream or frosting on a cake with ube powder will not impart any sort of health benefit.

The vegetable does contain potassium, magnesium and calcium, all of which can affect blood pressure, but not in the amounts added to foods or drinks. Claims of ube countering menopausal symptoms are usually based on its content of diosgenin, a compound that in the lab can be converted into progesterone. This reaction was fundamental to the development of the birth control pill. Back in the 1940s chemist Russell Marker found a way to synthesize progesterone from diosgenin he extracted from a wild Mexican yam. That reaction launched the modern steroid industry.

Progesterone, a steroid, was known to be a produced during pregnancy giving birth to the theory that administering progesterone to a woman would trick the body into believing that a pregnancy was under way and prevent the release of an egg from the ovaries. That turned out to be correct, and a modified version of progesterone was the basis of the first birth control pill. Furthermore, progesterone, usually combined with estrogen, was later shown to reduce menopausal symptoms. However, the claim that diosgenin in ube can reduce menopausal symptoms, is bogus. Diosgenin does not get converted into progesterone in the body.

The body’s inability to convert diosgenin into progesterone does not mean that ube has no physiological effect. Like all plants, it contains hundreds of naturally occurring chemicals, including some with possible estrogen-like activity. A study by Taiwanese researchers did show an increase in blood levels of estrone, an estrogen, that in theory could have an impact on menopausal symptoms. But the study involved only 22 subjects, and they were not drinking ube tea or licking ube ice cream. For a month, the women were asked to eat the tuber instead of rice, which was commonly their dietary staple, in two out of three daily meals. That is a lot of ube! There was also a small decrease in blood cholesterol as well as a decrease in urinary isoprostane, a marker of oxidation. Interesting, but using this small study using large doses of the vegetable to promote ube powder as a “health supplement” is totally unjustified.

What do we then make of the hubbub generated by social media about this purple tuber? One could theorize that eating ube regularly instead of potatoes would have some benefit because of its anthocyanin content. This, though, is an unrealistic situation in Canada or the U.S. Still, I think, I will give an ube smoothie a try, not because I expect any health benefit, but because it will give me yet another opportunity to launch into a discussion about the historical importance of the color purple.

Ah, the color purple! We can add a connection other than to synthetic chemistry. “The Color Purple” is the title of Alice Walker’s Pulitzer Prize-winning 1982 novel, later turned into a movie by Steven Spielberg. The title comes from a passage in the book about how “it pisses God off if you walk by the color purple in a field somewhere and don’t notice it.” The comment is aimed at Celie, played in the film by Whoopi Goldberg, a woman who has endured a tough life and is told that happiness can come from something as simple as recognizing beauty around her, such as a field of purple flowers. I can see that. Walking through a field of lavender in France made me happy.  But I can also see beauty in that purple tuber. Thanks to those social media influencers, I can now add “ube” to the list of substances I appreciate because of their purple colour. As well as to the list of claims that need to be debunked.


@‌JoeSchwarcz

Back to top