Technique involves use of non-invasive digital infrared imaging
According to the World Health Organization, approximately 180 000 deaths every year are caused by burns, with the majority occurring in low- and middle-income countries. Upon arriving at the emergency room with a burn, the patient undergoes a clinical inspection to assess both the severity of the lesion in relation to the affected area of the body and the depth of the injury (1st, 2nd or 3rd-degree burns). Based on this assessment and other considerations including bleeding and the extent of the damage, the surgical team makes a decision regarding management of the patient’s care.
However, because a wound can change its clinical characteristics in the days following the initial injury, when determining the best course of treatment clinical inspection alone has shown to be inaccurate in 30 to 50% of cases. Factor in the guidelines that suggest patients be followed for between 10 to 15 days before treating them with surgical intervention to allow the wound bed to heal and there is much uncertainty as to which treatment a patient will receive when they first present to the hospital.
To address this issue, researchers at McGill University’s Faculty of Medicine, working in collaboration with Universidad Autonoma de San Luis Potosi in Mexico, propose using non-invasive digital infrared thermography within the first three days of a patient suffering a burn in order to better predict the best mode of treatment. Their method is described in a paper published last fall in PLOS ONE. Akin to taking a picture using a special camera, the method is painless, quick to acquire and requires minimal training.
“Digital infrared thermography allows us to visualize the heat emitted by objects,” explains Dr. José Luis Ramírez García Luna, PhD candidate in the Department of Experimental Surgery at McGill and the paper’s corresponding author. “In the human body, heat emission depends on blood flow to the tissues, thus it is an indirect measurement of blood perfusion to the skin or a wound bed. Previous research has shown that the temperature of the skin correlates well with blood flow to it and that there are differences in the temperature pattern of healing vs. non-healing wounds.”
Predicting treatment with 90% accuracy
The researchers devised a clinical prediction rule for which treatment a patient with a large burn in an extremity would receive based on the thermal characteristics of the initial lesion. To obtain the thermal characteristics of the lesion, they first obtained digital thermograms with a thermal camera. They then recorded the difference in the average temperature of the burn and a patch of healthy adjacent skin.
Once the surgical team treated the patient as they normally would, after discharge the researchers categorized the treatment given as re-epithelization if the wound healed by itself, as skin graft if the patient received at least one, or as amputation if any extremity had to be removed due to extensive damage to it. Finally, using a machine learning method, they created a prediction model to categorize treatment based on the clinical data and the thermograms, discovering that the temperature difference between the healthy skin and the wound alone is enough to make the prediction. The accuracy of the prediction using their algorithm was found to be 90% both in the development cohort of patients, as well as in an independent validation cohort.
“We believe our method could become a useful tool for the early assessment of patients in the emergency department, as well as in the later stages of patient care to identify dead tissue, distinguish between partial and full-thickness burns and detect complications such as the presence of infection or lack of blood flow,” notes Dr. Ramírez García Luna. “In our opinion, the most relevant contribution of our method to wound care is in allowing the clinical team to rapidly and objectively determine the treatment modality that is most likely needed, thereby preventing unnecessary procedures or delays in surgery. Because this has implications in selecting which patients may benefit more from certain interventions, and which will not, it is very likely that it can be translated to lowering costs related to treatment and hospital stay, as well as in reducing the length of hospital stay for the patients.”
The researchers are currently conducting a randomized trial in the same hospital in Mexico where they developed the prediction rule and are looking for potential collaborators in other burn units in order to test their method in other scenarios to complete an external validation of it. They are also very interested in sharing it with clinicians treating patients in constrained resource settings.
PLOS ONE, Martínez-Jiménez,et al, “Development and validation of an algorithm to predict the treatment modality of burn wounds using thermographic scans: Prospective cohort study”
For more information, contact Dr. José Luis Ramírez García Luna at jose.ramirezgarcialuna [at] mail.mcgill.ca