University Appeals Committee

Terms of Reference:

An Extract from the Regulations on Appeals of Tenure Decisions (approved by Senate on February 18, 2015):

7.1 There shall be an Appeals Committee for hearing appeals of the final decision of the Principal against recommending a grant of tenure.

7.2 The Appeals Committee shall consist of ten (10) members of the academic staff, appointed to staggered terms of office of three (3) years, commencing on September 1st.

7.3 The appointments shall be approved by Senate and the Board of Governors, following the nominating process set out below.

7.4 Prior to the March 1st of each year, the Secretary-General shall request from the President of the McGill Association of University Teachers (M.A.U.T.) and the Principal a slate of names consisting of at least twice the number of vacancies on the Appeals Committee to be filled that year.

7.5 The slate of recommended names shall be submitted by the President of M.A.U.T. and the Principal to the Secretary-General for consideration by the Senate Nominating Committee. From this slate, the Senate Nominating Committee shall select the persons to recommend to Senate to fill the vacancies. Reasonable efforts shall be made to give due consideration to gender representation as well as representation from different faculties when appointing members to the Appeals Committee.

7.6 To be eligible to serve, the staff member shall be a tenured member of the full-time academic staff who is on active employment with the University, and available to serve for the full term of the appointment.

7.7 The Appeals Committee shall select a Chair and Vice Chair annually from amongst the serving members.


(3-year terms commencing September 1st)

Professor John Silvius (Biochemistry, MEDICINE) – 2018  
Professor Jane Everett (French Language and Literature, ARTS) - 2018
Professor Marilyn Fitzpatrick (Educational and Counselling Psychology, EDUCATION)- 2018
Professor Marilyn Scott (Parasitology, FAES) - 2018
Professor Tim Moore (Geography, SCIENCE) - 2018

Professor Andrew Kirk (Electrical and Computer Engineering, ENGINEERING) - 2019
Professor Gillian Lane-Mercier (Department of French Language and Literature, ARTS) – 2019
Professor Tamara Western (Biology, SCIENCE) - 2019

Professor Jacques Hurtubise (Mathematics and Statistics, SCIENCE) - 2020
Professor Peter Grütter (Physics, SCIENCE) - 2020 

Secretary: Ms. Bonnie Borenstein