Quick Links

Sustainability amidst uncertainty: Columbia Forest Products’ Pursuit of sustainability in a changing market

Company name
Columbia Forest Products

Author(s)
Scott Marshall, Zachary Anderson, Matthew Flax, Daniel Gambetta, Jacen Greene-Powell and Madeleine Pullman 

Source 
OIKOS (3rd place, Global Case Writing Competition 2009, Corporate Sustainability Track)

Access this case
Sustainability amidst uncertainty: Columbia Forest Products’ Pursuit of sustainability in a changing market

Year published 
2009

Last year covered in case 
2008

Abstract
From its humble beginnings as a small shuttered plywood mill, Columbia Forest Products has grown to be one of the largest players in the U.S. hardwood plywood products market. This case follows the company’s introduction of a new sustainable plywood product in an extremely competitive and economically challenging market place. At the point in the case, the construction of new homes had fallen across the United States. 

The fate of Columbia Forest Products (CFP) was tightly bound to the US housing market.  CFP has over a 40% market share in hardwood plywood products, most of which go into new home construction.  Further, over the past three years, CFP has embarked on a journey into sustainability.  This journey is marked most profoundly by the introduction of PureBond© non-formaldehyde plywood in 2006.  A first in the industry, PureBond© provides significant health benefits to CFP employees and customers by removing a known carcinogen from its products.  It also has been a catalyst for CFP to pursue a more comprehensive, sustainability-inspired strategy.  But in the midst of the dreadful housing market in the US, CFP executive team wondered if further pursuit of a sustainability strategy would be detrimental to their company’s competitiveness.

The threat of domestic and international competition is ever present and the company is well aware that the advantage provided by PureBond© is only temporary.  CFP’s domestic competition will be able to offer competitive non-formaldehyde products in 1 ½ to 2 years.  It would likely take China and other overseas manufacturers another year at least to offer comparable products.  

Another consideration is CFP’s reputation.  It has spent many years building recognition for its sustainability initiatives.  By further pursuing a sustainability-based strategy, CFP invites greater public scrutiny.  CFP needs to be clear on how it commits itself to sustainability and the reputation that it built as a result.  There is always the potential that well intentioned and ambitious sustainability efforts can turn into PR disasters. 

This case describes the issues and dilemmas facing the company in deciding to adopt a sustainability strategy. The case is designed to highlight decisions related to strategy, adverse industry reactions, public policy and health claims, etc. In addition, it provides an example of a product developed through biomimicry. The case can draw on the following frameworks: Porter’s Five Forces Model, Resource Based Theory and Systems Dynamics.

Teaching note

Key Management Reading

  • Ambec, S. & Lanoie, P. (2008). Does it pay to be green? A systematic overview. Academy of Management Perspectives. 45-62
  • Reinhardt, F. (1999). Bringing the Environment Down to Earth. Harvard Business Review. July; 149-157 

Other Readings

  • Wilson M, Schwarzman M, Malloy T, Fanning E, Sinsheimer P. (2008) Green Chemistry: Cornerstone to a Sustainable California. Special Report to the California Environmental Protection Agency. University of California Centers for Occupational and Environmental Health
  • Poliakoff, M., & Anastas, P. (2001). A principled stance. Nature, 413(6853), 257.
  • Hjeresen, D.L., Kirchoff, M.M., Lankley, R.L. (2002) Green Chemistry: Environment, economics and competitiveness. Corporate Environmental Strategy, 9(3). 259-266
  • Manley, Anastas, Cue. (2008) Frontiers in Green Chemistry: meeting the grand challenges for sustainability in R&D and manufacturing. Journal of cleaner production. 16:743-750
  • Larson, A. (2006) Illustrating the Finanical Benefits of Green Chemistry. Darden Business Publishing.

Audio/Visual Material

Discussion Questions

  • Which principles of green chemistry are used in this case?
  • How do the principles of green chemistry translate into business benefits? (E.g. Reduced toxic waste = managing environmental risk; Less toxic end product = product differentiation)
  • Are there tradeoffs between the different principles? (E.g. Waste is reduced (Principle 1), but process used more energy (Principle 6); End product is less hazardous (Principle 4) but process to make it is less green (Principle 3); Uses a renewable feedstock (Principle 7) but the new process uses toxic solvents (Principle 5))

Green Chemistry Principle

  • Principle 3 Less Hazardous Synthesis
  • Principle 4 Design for Benign Chemicals

Industry
Building and Architecture

Teaching Topic
Business Government Relations
Employee Ownership
Environmental Issues
Innovation
Private/Non-profit Partnerships
Social Marketing
Social Process of Production
Stakeholder Relationships
Sustainability

Management Discipline
Business Government and Society
Management
Marketing
Strategy

Business Logic
Differentiating Products
Managing Competitors
Redefining Markets
Reduced Cost

Environmental Issue
Air Pollution
Biomimicry
Deforestation
Toxicity

Self Identified as Green Chemistry?
No

    Desautels Faculty of Management on Social Media

    Desautels Faculty of Management at McGill on FacebookDesautels Faculty of Management at McGill on TwitterDesautels Faculty of Management at McGill, BCom Program on LinkedInDesautels Faculty of Management at McGill, MBA Program on LinkedInDesautels Faculty of Management at McGill on YouTube

    Research at Desautels Faculty of Management

    Accounting at Desautels Faculty of ManagementFinance at Desautels Faculty of ManagementInformation Systems at Desautels Faculty of ManagementMarketing at Desautels Faculty of ManagementOperations Management at Desautels Faculty of ManagementOrganizational Behaviour at Desautels Faculty of ManagementStrategy and Organization at Desautels Faculty of ManagementHealth Care at Desautels Faculty of Management